Author/ Authority
-Do they have their masters?
-Do they have a PHD?
-Are they a hobbyist?
-Respectable organization?
Date/Currency
How current is the information?
- Health and Medicine
- Business
- Technology
Intended Audience
-Newspaper
-Magazines
-Scholarly Journal
-Trade article
Evidence
Bias
Looking for Bias
Lack of citations
The information below can help you understand the differences between scholarly journals, professional/trade journals, and popular periodicals.
Criteria | Scholarly Journals | Professional/Trade Journals | Popular Periodicals/ Magazines |
---|---|---|---|
Audience | Researchers and experts | Members of a trade or profession | The general public |
Author | Researchers and experts | Staff writers and experts in the field | Staff writers, although many articles are unsigned |
References (Sources cited) | Includes reference lists and bibliography. All quotes and facts are documented. | Reference lists sometimes included. | References rarely included. |
Purpose | To disseminate research findings | To publicize current topics in the field and professional issues | To disseminate general information or to entertain |
Content | Detailed research reports and methodologies | Trends, standards, and new technologies in the field | General interest stories and news; may include personal narrative and opinions |
Language | Jargon that assumes expertise in the field | Jargon that assumes expertise in the field | Language that requires no expertise |
Publisher | Associations or universities | Associations | Commercial organizations |
Layout | Highly structured organization; includes abstract, bibliography, charts or graphs | Structured organization; usually includes abstract, bibliography, charts or graphs | Informal organization: eye-catching type and format; includes illustrations or photographs |
Examples | Journal of the American Medical Association; Political Science Quarterly | Hospital Business Week; Real Estate Weekly News; Farm Industry News | Time; Newsweek; Science News |