Skip to Main Content

ENGL 202B: Effective Writing: Writing in the Humanities

UNDERSTANDING SCHOLARSHIP AS A CONVERSATION

An academic discipline is a community that is structured around a particular area of study. The scholarship undertaken by researchers in this kind of community is a lot like a conversation. Researchers enter into a dialogue with an existing body of knowledge in an attempt to create new knowledge. 

An article in a scholarly journal, like Home visitor readiness, job support, and job satisfaction across three home visitation programs: A Retrospective Analysis by Laura Nathans, Sukhdeep Gill, Sonia Molloy, and Mark Greenberg, is an example of how this process is done in the study of human development and family studies. It represents a contribution to a much broader discussion. Specifically, they are studying newly hired home visitors' "perceptions of their job readiness, initial training, supervision and support, commitment to the intervention model, and job satisfaction."

As social science researchers, Nathans, et. all, craft this article in ways that speak directly to other scholars doing similar research. To motivate and support her argument with this audience, they present a wealth of evidence through parenthetical citations. This evidence bolsters their credibility. But it can also be used to formulate a research focus of your own. Each source cited is a conversational thread that can be followed.

Let’s say, for example, you were interested in learning more about how commitment to an organization's philosophy affects home visitors [see the passage below].

Human Development and Family Studies article text

How could you find more information? You can start by looking at the parenthetical citations (e.g., Tarigan & Ariani or Korfmacher, et.al.) and finding them in the References.

human development and family studies reference one

human development and family studies reference two

You can mine references like these to find more relevant articles.

MINING AN ARTICLE FOR CITATIONS

(adapted from https://guides.library.appstate.edu/researchstrategies/citation_mining)

Mining citations of a relevant article/book can help you find more potentially useful resources.. 

  • All of the references in article by Nathans, et.al. look back in time
    • To determine if Penn State has access to the article's full-text, search the article title in the main search box on the University Libraries’ main page. https://libraries.psu.edu/

human development and family studies lion search box

  • If it’s a book, search the title (e.g. What Can and Can't Be Said: Race, Uplift, and Monument Building in the Contemporary South) in our online catalog, the CAT
     
  • You can also search Google Scholar for items.
    • Search tip:  When searching Google Scholar always come via the library website so you won't be prompted to pay for resources we have.
    • Search part of all of the article title.

human development and family studies google scholar result

Click the "Cited By" link to see the items that have cited the original work.

NOTE: If Penn State does not have access to a particular article or book, you can always request that item through Interlibrary Loan.

FORMULATING A FOCUS

As you read these articles, pay attention to the language researchers use to describe the concepts or events you're researching.

Being prepared with terms to search will allow you to:

  • Broaden or narrow your focus to include related concepts and events.
  • Find other relevant articles in the literature that are not cited in the original article.

Below is a subject guide that will get you started searching for relevant literature in your field. That said, there are many other resources that could be helpful. Look at everything listed under Education and Psychology on this page.

As you locate articles, look closely at their individual records. Many of them will have something called Subject Terms. These are how databases organize information, tagging all articles on the same topic with same Subject Term. Often, they contain lots of jargon and/or odd punctuation. But finding relevant terms can help you find relevant articles. [See highlighted text in example below.]

subject terms